Reasoning about software quality attributes sei digital library. Scenarios the quality attribute scenarios represent a core component of the workshop. How to write meaningful quality attributes for software development. The stimulus is a condition that needs to be considered when it arrives at a system. To do this, we use the qualityattributespecific tables to create general scenarios and from these derive systemspecific scenarios. Is where the desired vague software behaviors are turned. Aqualityattributescenarioisaquality attribute specificrequirement. For softwaredevelopment teams that need an effective yet inexpensive method for eliciting quality requirements with stakeholders, the miniqaw is a lean workshop that quickly and costeffectively helps teams identify and prioritize quality attribute scenarios. Raw scenarios are a flexible, informal way to describe requirements with regards to quality. Portion of scenario possible values source organization stimulus competitive pressure, lack of development team artifacts deployment environment during development of product. A quality attribute scenario is an unambiguous way to specify a testable quality attribute. Jonathan aldrich 15 3 foundations of software engineering quality attribute scenarios and architectural tactics 1 9 september 2008 15 3 foundations of software engineering software architecture bck03 bass clements and kazman software architecture in practice addison wesley 2003 source 2 environment the measure by which the response is evaluated 3 the activity that.
The safety quality attribute may be specified by hazard scenarios in 1 the use of scenarios for assessing architectures is also identified. The achievement of these quality attribute related responses brings benefit to the stakeholders in the behavior of. Quality attributes, contexts and challenges charlie. Attributes of quality scenarios scenario sets used in software requirements elicitation kimberly a.
A quality attribute scenario is composed of six elements as the. Within systems engineering, quality attributes are realized nonfunctional requirements used to evaluate the performance of a system. Artifact what elements of the system are stimulated. Scenariobased assessment of software architecture usability. To reason about architectural patterns, we must first characterize the quality attribute requirements. With this, squa3re provides a contribution to align are efforts with architectural. In this report, we define software quality, introduce a generic taxonomy of attributes, discuss the connections between the attributes, and discuss future work leading to an attribute. Project a developed financial support software for a midsize firm. Quality attributes scenarios originated as a way to evaluate software architecture. The team decides to leverage the architecture tradeoff analysis method atam 1 utility tree to better understand quality attributes by documenting the quality attribute refinements e. Attributes of quality scenariosscenario sets used in software requirements elicitation kimberly a. Apr 18, 2020 quality attributes scenarios in software architecture.
Last time we figured out the role, skills, and duties of a software architect. In software engineering, the use cases describe what functions the user wants to be implemented, while quality attribute scenarios contain the description of how well the functions have to perform within the designed application. Because they have explicit stimuli and responses, we can evaluate a design in terms of how likely it is to support the scenario, and we can take measurements and test a prototype or fully fleshedout system for whether it satisfies the scenario in practice. Quality attributes, contexts and challenges charlie alfred. Software architects need to understand their designs in terms of quality attributes. Correctness, reliability, adequacy, learnability, robustness, maintainability, readability, extensibility, testability, efficiency, portability. Foundations of software eng ineering software architecture 3 quality attribute scenarios bck03 stimulus a condition that affects a system source of stimulus the entity that generates the stimulus environment the condition under which the stimulus occurred artifact the artifact that was. Software architects may use this information to assess which nosql. In this material, well make a short overview of 12 software architecture quality attributes and quality attributes types. Quality attributes and quality attribute scenarios. To make the general scenarios useful for a particular system, you must make them system specific. Aqualityattributescenarioisaqualityattributespecificrequirement. More about each basss seven quality attributes scenarios for each, with examples this info is the main appendix to your suppl spec template. Attributes of quality scenariosscenario sets used in.
Together, reliability, availability, serviceability, usability and installability, are referred to as rasui. We also show how the principles provide a context for existing evaluation approaches such as scenarios, questionnaires, checklists, and measurements. A quality attribute scenario is a qualityattributespecific requirement. In their book, evaluating software architectures, rick kazman, paul clements, and mark klein observe. This article will give you a list of software quality attributes in quality assurance and quality control. Quality attribute workshops ensure that quality attribute. Quality attribute scenarios catalog no longer for sale some years ago we offered a quality attributes scenarios catalog. While it is common to omit one or more of these six parts, particularly in the early stages of thinking about quality attributes, knowing that all parts are there forces the architect to consider whether each part is relevant. Quality attribute scenario example in software architecture thank. And when writing concrete quality attribute scenarios the architect usually starts with four core elements. Independence of the actual application of the software. System quality attributes quality attribute scenarios. Writing quality attribute scenarios that everyone agrees on.
Forming quality attribute scenarios for business and architectural qualities scenarios for business quality attributes. The software supported the buying and selling of financial securities. This is some entity a human, a computer system, or any other actuator that generated the stimulus. We characterize quality attributes using general scenarios and codify architectural as quality attribute design primitives or attribute primitives. The ultimate goal is the ability to quantitatively evaluate and trade off multiple software quality attributes to arrive at a better overall system. Jonathan aldrich 15 3 foundations of software engineering quality attribute scenarios and architectural tactics 1 9 september 2008 15 3 foundations of software engineering software architecture bck03 bass clements and kazman software architecture in practice addison wesley 2003 source 2 environment the measure by which the. As we said in chapter 1, a systems quality attribute requirements are seldom elicited and recorded in a disciplined way. These scenarios, in addition to describing the direct interaction of some enduser with the software system, also describe a quality attribute of the system e. Each is potentially but not necessarily relevant to the system you are concerned with. How to write meaningful quality attributes for software. The way to get that concrete understanding of the effect of quality attributes is to use scenarios. Apr 14, 2019 the quality attribute scenarios represent a core component of the workshop. To do this, we use the quality attribute specific tables to create general scenarios and from these derive systemspecific scenarios. To define a tangible quality attribute, a good starting point is to write a quality attribute scenario.
As typical examples, quality attributes can be constraints, assumptions, and objectives of stakeholders. The purpose of this report is to take a small step in the direction of developing a unifying approach for reasoning about multiple software quality attributes. Finally, for each quality attribute refinement, the team documents at least one scenario that illustrates how the quality attribute requirement is being met. Software architecture in practice, 2nd edition by bass, clements and kazman. The here described quality attribute are fairly common in nearly all systems, but there exist many other quality attributes that are domain and product specific. Software quality is an important concern of the software developers and customers. Quality attribute workshops ensure that quality attribute scenarios are identified, prioritized, and refined before the software architecture is completed. Variation is a concept associated with software product lines see chapter 14. We now discuss the six most common and important system quality attributes.
It was a tool for disciplined software architects or apprentices who took their role seriously. Therefore, we named our approach software quality attribute analysis by architecture reconstruction squa3re. A situation in which the system has the desired combination of quality attributes, for example, of usability and performance or reliability, shows the success of the architecture and the quality of the software. Quality attributes scenarios in software architecture. When the system requirements are defined, it is essential also to define what is expected regarding these quality attributes, since these expectations will guide the planning of the system architecture and design. The results of this exercise are documented in a utility tree see chapter 3 for a detailed discussion of the quality attribute utility tree using the structure that we are now familiar with. Understanding quality attributes universidad icesi. Quality attributes rosehulman institute of technology. Quality attribute scenarios and architectural tactics are some of the tools available for the creation of an architecture. Software qualities such as maintainability can be expressed very naturally through change scenarios.
Scenarios are short, user storylike proses that demonstrate how a quality attribute is manifested in the system using a functional situation. A raw scenario usually consists of a single sentence and gets assigned to a quality attribute by placing it inside the web. Software architects need to be aware of the driving quality attributes. Many of these quality attributes can also be applied to data quality. Using quality attributes as a means to improve acquisition. General scenarios are system independent scenarios with typical stimuli, responses, and response measures for. Software quality attributes play a drastic role in software testing industry. Such a longterm perspective, however, can be hard to maintain in a hightempo, agile delivery model, which is why the sei continues to recommend an architecture. It was for architects who saw value in writing quality attribute scenarios to help them create or select software architecture.
We distinguish general quality attribute scenarios which we call general scenarios for shortthose that are system independent and can, potentially, pertain to any systemfrom concrete quality attribute scenarios concrete scenariosthose that are specific to the particular system under consideration. Quality attribute scenario an overview sciencedirect topics. We remedy this situation by generating concrete quality attribute scenarios. Quality attribute scenario an overview sciencedirect. Software quality attributes are the benchmarks that describe a systems behavior within an environment. They are usually architecturally significant requirements that require architects attention. Quality attributes in software architecture nikolay ashanin medium. The quality attributes provide the means for measuring the fitness and suitability of a product. Environment what are the conditions when the stimulus occurs. Qualities that are about the architecture itself 3. Another technique is a utility tree, which is a hierarchically organized af nity grouping of quality attribute concerns and scenarios derived from a particular project. Software quality attribute analysis by architecture. Quality attributes scenarios in software architecture youtube.
Learn how to write meaningful quality attributes for software development. We know from existing sei work on attributedriven design, quality attribute workshops, and the architecture tradeoff analysis method that a focus on quality attributes prevents costly rework. Functionality, usability, reliability, performance and supportability are together referred to as furps in relation to software requirements. Henceforth, the main contributions of this article can be summarized as follows. Is where the desired vague software behaviors are turned into tangible and measurable goals. We considered who is a software architect, what types of software architects exist, and what the architect. Sep 08, 2014 we believe refinement of qars using scenarios creates a reasonably sized chunk of work for analysis, implementation, and possibly even testing during an iteration. The quality of software systems may be expressed as a collection of software quality attributes. A quality attribute scenario is a qualityattributespeci. For five important quality attributes modifiability, performance, availability, security and usability, we have enumerated a collection of quality attribute general scenarios that are intended to encompass all of the generally accepted meanings for these quality attribute. This finding strengthens our contention that our use of acquisition quality attributes and acquisition quality attribute scenarios is analogous to the use of software quality attribute and software quality attribute scenarios and that we may continue to rely on methods and mechanisms developed for that purpose to assist with the creation of. Individual requirements are viewed in a forum in relation to one another in the context of the overall problem. When designing to meet any requirements, it is important to consider the impact on other attributes and find compromises between.
Software testability refers to the ease with which software can be made. Quality attribute scenarios and architectural tactics. A quality attribute scenario is composed of six elements as the following figure illustrates. Copyright 2003 by carnegie mellon university sponsored by. Qaw is mainly addressing nonfunctional requirements and there is still needs to understand the problems we try to solve, gather functional requirements like in business scenarios. The development of a qualityattribute oriented evaluation of nosql databases table 2. Thisissomeentityahuman,acomputersystem,oranyother actuator. Quality attributes and quality attribute scenarios are concepts that were popularized by the software engineering institute in the early 2000s. Quality attribute scenario example in software architecture.
In their book, evaluating software architectures, rick kazman, paul. The purpose of this report is to take a small step in the direction of developing a unifying approach for. A general scenario is in effect a template for generating a specific. Next, well look at what exactly each attribute means individually. Download table quality attributes scenario and an example. A raw scenario usually consists of a single sentence. Some years ago we offered a quality attributes scenarios catalog. But what happens when functional requirements are formulated and software architect found the way how the system should work. The use of software metrics within an organization is expected to have a beneficial effect by making software quality more visible. The impact of scenarios, like usecases, can be traced through a software system. General scenarios provide a framework for generating a large number of generic, systemindependent, qualityattributespecific scenarios.
General scenarios provide a framework for generating a large number of generic, systemindependent, quality attribute specific scenarios. In chapter 7, we discuss how to apply these tools in designing an architecture and in building a skeletal system, and how the architecture is reflected in the organizational structure. New conclusions and insights derived from the quality attribute based analysis of several nosql databases. This is a air force inst of tech wrightpattersonafb oh report procured by the pentagon and made available for public release. However, the use of metrics does not eliminate the need for human judgment in software assessment. Quality attributes in software architecture nikolay ashanin. It has been reproduced in the best form available to the pentagon. Miniquality attribute workshop reflections on software. If system is using all the available resources then the user will get degraded performance failing the system for efficiency. For example, the system should utilize processor capacity, disk space and memory efficiently. Software architecture has a profound affect on most qualities in one way or another and software quality attributes affect architecture. Next, we defined an approach for expressing programspecific acquisition quality attribute scenarios using the seis earlier work in software architecture where stakeholders are encouraged to create small stories that specify some event the stimulus that occurs in a particular part of the lifecycle the environment and a desired behavior. Qualityoriented software product line architecture design software.
867 722 452 1198 470 590 924 20 815 223 1316 634 1403 116 689 275 290 1204 1408 1476 1472 256 716 860 1241 1022 165 1301 1431 339